Tiny Tim's Pizza

Discover Tiny Tim's Pizza in Fayetteville, AR, offering freshly made, thin crust pizzas, delicious meathead pizza, meatball subs, and craft beers. Enjoy downtown location, homemade ranch dressing, and quick service. Call +1 479-521-5551 for your local pizza experience!

Welcome to Tiny Tim's Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Tiny Tim's Pizza
Tiny Tim's Pizza
Tiny Tim's Pizza
Tiny Tim's Pizza

Tiny Tim's Pizza invites you to indulge in a slice of tradition and taste right in downtown Fayetteville. Located at 21 W Mountain St, this pizza restaurant crafts authentic, homemade pizzas that locals rave about. Enjoy favorites like the Meathead pizza or the freshly made meatball sub, paired expertly with their famous homemade ranch dressing. The inviting atmosphere makes it a go-to spot for families, friends, and anyone craving delicious comfort food. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a cozy dinner, Tiny Tim's offers a delightful experience with each visit. And with a bustling weekend scene, you’ll find the place filled with good vibes and great people.

Tiny Tim's Pizza stands out with its commitment to quality and flavor. Dine on gourmet pizzas from their diverse menu, featuring unique choices like the Crazy Italian or Polynesian Pizza. The craft beer selection complements the meal perfectly, enhancing the dining experience. Other highlights include their sandwiches, salads, and the option for personal-sized pizzas, catering to all appetites. The restaurant maintains a cozy and welcoming vibe, complete with friendly service that makes every guest feel special.

With an average price of just $8.77, Tiny Tim's Pizza delivers excellent value, ensuring that satisfaction is just as important as flavor.

Busiest days are a testament to its popularity, especially Saturdays at noon. Planning a visit? To avoid crowds, aim for less busy times like Monday afternoons or early dinner hours on weekdays. This way, you can focus on enjoying your meal without any wait.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

21 W Mountain St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, United States

Phone

+1 479-521-5551

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Tiny Tim's Pizza
Tiny Tim's Pizza
Tiny Tim's Pizza
Tiny Tim's Pizza

Tiny Tim's Pizza has carved out a special niche in Fayetteville's vibrant food scene. With a diverse menu that includes heaps of options for everyone, it serves as a community hotspot. The restaurant's dedication to freshly made ingredients translates into each dish, ensuring that every slice bursts with flavor. Popular choices like the meatball sub and the thin crust pizza continue to attract regulars and newcomers alike. Beyond the food, Tiny Tim's fosters a sense of community, making it a favorite gathering spot for locals.

The menu features not just pizzas but also a variety of sandwiches and salads, all made with the freshest ingredients.

Options range from gourmet pizzas like 'There's A Fungus Amongus' to delightful salads, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Tiny Tim's pizza pays close attention to details, from homemade sauces, including their beloved ranch dressing, to the crafting of each pizza with precision. Regulars often find themselves returning not just for the taste but for the welcoming environment that feels like a home away from home.

Its optimal downtown location makes it a convenient stop for a quick meal or a leisurely dining experience.

The friendly staff and lively atmosphere enhance the offers. Even on the busiest days, the service remains upbeat and cheerful, creating an inviting space that keeps diners coming back. Plus, for those looking to unwind, the selection of local craft beers pairs wonderfully with a slice, crafting the ultimate Fayetteville experience. Due to its popularity, visiting during off-peak times like early afternoons or weekdays can significantly enhance the dining experience, allowing for a more leisurely meal.

Tiny Tim's Pizza

Tiny Tim's Pizza occupies a charming spot on West Mountain Street, glowing with vibrant energy. The exterior reflects the cozy ambiance inside, inviting passersby to step in and explore the menu. Outdoor seating adds to the experience, providing a casual vibe where diners can enjoy the fresh air while savoring their pizza. The atmosphere buzzes with laughter and conversation, particularly during peak hours when locals gather to share good food and stories.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Came in with my wife and two sons (toddler and 4 mo) during the lights on the square. Totally expected to be standing in line forever but Wes took us across the restaurant and got us seated very promptly. Our waitress Brittany let us know out the gate how long our expected time would be for our food which I appreciated. Place was packed and when Brittany was busy with a massive birthday party table Wes came over and refilled our beers. Pizza was cooked to perfection, family had a great time, and the beer was awesome. Big shout outs to Wes and Brittany for being exceptionally professional in an intensely busy food service situation. Also shout out to Hailey for talking to and being friendly my son.

k
kellyh S.

Still the best pizza in NWA for 20+yrs, unique crust, THE best sauce, pepperoni isn't greasy like some others. Our whole family loves it.

A
Adam B.

Great pizza when it's on! Like other places during this slowdown and service, there are times when the pizza is not so good. But by large when they're on their game, it's hard to beat :-) highly recommend trying it!

b
big k.

We have been patrons of Tim's for many years. We have always had awesome servers, Great people!! Although the menu is simple one -- IT'S SIMPLE & EASY. That is one of the things that we have always enjoyed. The Pizzamakers, in my opinion, try to do a very good job - so let's give credit where credit is due. Definitely glad they are still in business!! And, if you like craft beers... ??? They have a great & tasty selection!!

L
Lee

Had a meathead pizza. Large is 15 inches 10 / slices. Pizza quality is above average. They make it very light on sauce which I prefer, but some may not. Waitress was very nice. Prices are good, too, honestly. Overall, I give it an A or 5/5.

D
Dan P.

Ordered large Crazy Italian. It was tasty with a bit of a crispy crust. Was enough for a family of three with some leftover. Would like to try again to explore the menu a bit more. Overall a good experience.

J
James C.